Well, I came prepared.
I brought some sewing and a DVD to watch on the 'puter. The newest BBC "Sense and Sensibility", (imdb-entry with list of cast etc. here)and my present "carry along and work on forever" project. Rectangle hexagons.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0294f/0294f972a3565f55cb7cc3e804e3827b1ff3e24a" alt=""
And how do I like it ?
Well ... its major flaw is, that it is not the Emma Thompson version. The only thing that was clearly better in this one, was Edward Ferrars. I like Hugh Grant a lot, and find him charming in 4 weddings and Notting Hill, but I think his playing EF in the old (movie) version, was the one disastrous mis-casting in that one.
The major flaw with the new one, however, is (to me) that I cannot see Willoughby as instantly appealing. He is not at all appealing, romantic or dashing to me. I found his acting in Mamma Mia flat and unintersting, and thought it probably had to do with having a quite uninteresting part, but that does not seem to be the case. To any and all of you who love him, I apologize. He simply does not click with me.
I can sympathize with Marianne not falling instantly in love with Brandon in this version, and her eventual joining up with him, but ... Willoughby ... no.
I guess that Willoughby, Wickham (in P&P), and Henry Crawford (MP) have the same problem. They need to be charming, handsome and urbane, but also need to be seriously bad news ... and to find a young enough actor to pull that off seems very difficult indeed.
So. Do I recommend this version ? I really don't know. As I wrote, the major flaw is, that it is not the Emma Thompson movie, and for someone who does not have that sort of prejudice, or disliked the movie, I think this one could be a very good introduction to S&S.
And this concludes my first "task" in the Jane Austen Challenge.
4 comments:
Who played the part of Willoughby?
And thanks for the critique--I love the Emma Thompson version, too. I also thought Hugh Grant kinda wishy-washy!!
I too much prefer the Emma Thompson version of S&S. I can't wait to watch it again (after I finish the book)!!
These blocks are very interesting!
hmmm, i'm re-thinking if i want to add this to my netflix. thanks for your review. i do love the one with emma thompson. love the colors of your hexagons.
Post a Comment